buttons i made, PLease give me some CC

I made these buttons for someone, please don't use them but can you please tell me what you think:






if its worth it, ill make a step to step tutorial of how to make these!

thanks!

those are pretty awesome... but simple.... you see, many people can make just right if they know how to work a good art program. I use photoshop CS3 and I could wip those up in a couple of minutes. I do see the circlish button, but thats just basic Filter>Spherisize.

I like the shine effect, although it is quite simple as well...

Im not saying they are bad, but I am saying they have been done before... simply....

anyway, good job.

Cheers,

Challenger

P.S.: Don't judge me by this post... I am just expressing my opinion, thats all . Sorry if this offends you.

of course it doesn't offend me
i know these are simple and can be wipped up quickly

Yea they look good except like challenger said the circles in the middle are too visible honestly I think you could do without that . and the shine does look goood. Simple and Effective.

I can't do that so gj

- JuNki3

thanks for the info!

anyway, is there anything else i can do to improve these?

you could reduce the change in colors
The middle has a too abrupt change... |/|